, , , , , , , , , , ,

The recipe that started it all

Written by

·

For all the success this blog has had (thanks to you, the readers!!!), I only started it in mid February of 2012. I really don’t know why it took me so long to find this calling. When I was in second grade, I wanted to write books. In college, I was a Journalism major. I have loved to cook for many years, but never really put it all together. Not until I saw a post on Eatocracy on inventive ways to serve peanut butter and jelly. First off, do we really need inventive ways? Give me a spoon and a jar! The post had five ideas and the first was Peanut Butter and Jelly French Toast. I saw it and had to make it! I then posted my making of it on Facebook. The idea spread from there.

Decadent. Truly decadent.

My major addition was to add in bananas.

Start by putting the whole jar of jelly in a saucepan. Over low to medium low heat, slowly heat it up. Stir frequently until is becomes a sauce.

If you are not going to use bananas, spread the peanut butter thick. With bananas, a little less so. Next time, I’ll put more on each slice.

Elvis would be proud.

Pa…the French Toast is looking mighty thick!

A little confectioners sugar doesn’t hurt.

P B & B & J French Toast

Ingredients:

  • 8 slices of bread
  • Peanut butter
  • Jar of jelly
  • 4 eggs
  • 1/2 tsp vanilla
  • Milk
  • Bananas

Directions:

Start by taking two slices of your favorite bread (day-old is just fine for this) and spread a thick layer of peanut butter on one slice and slice bananas and place on the bottom piece of bread. Close the sandwich with the other piece of bread.

Dip it in a mixture of egg, vanilla and milk (just like you would for traditional French toast) and fry the sandwich in a pan with a little butter.

In the meantime, use a small saucepan and a low flame to gently heat some grape juice concentrate or grape jelly until it reaches a syrup-like consistency. Serve the French toast with the grape syrup for a nutty twist on a classic brunch dish.

SOURCE: http://eatocracy.cnn.com/2012/02/09/55-new-twists-on-pbj/?iref=allsearch

59 responses to “The recipe that started it all”

  1. hollyeatsinfrance Avatar

    Love it. A great way to success!

    Like

  2. rigmover Avatar
    rigmover

    Well done, and now I’m hungry.

    Like

  3. Regina (Gina) Arnold Avatar

    OMG! Decadent for sure. Congratulations on your success.

    Like

  4. summerlandstyle Avatar

    Oh my! We just may have to try this with some gluten free bread. Decadent!

    Like

  5. Auntie Heather Avatar

    Sounds delicious, now I just have to translate your recipe into English English and I can make it myself: So, jelly – that’s what we Brits call jam, right? This recipe’s easier than some! Keep up the good work :o)

    Like

  6. Sara Avatar

    I can’t wait to try this! My kids will love it.

    Like

  7. Andrew Avatar

    That looks pretty amazing. Congrats on the success of the blog. I would not have guessed that it was only a few months old.

    Like

  8. JRJ2015 Avatar
    JRJ2015

    this looks so good…

    Like

  9. terry1954 Avatar

    now that looks so yummy. i will make it for my brother!

    Like

  10. Deborah DeLong Avatar

    Very tasty!! 🙂

    Like

  11. veghotpot Avatar

    That looks extremely delicious! I love peanut butter and bananas together its such a match made in foodie heaven!

    Like

  12. wifemeetslife Avatar

    I make banana French toast served with jelly all the time; I never thought to add peanut butter though!

    You’ll have to share the secret to your success; my blog is gaining popularity but I’d like to see it grow. Congrats on your success!

    Like

  13. Bob Vivant Avatar

    Absolutely lip-smacking! Sounds like Saturday breakfast to me. Thank you!

    Like

  14. Expat Alien Avatar

    OMG, decadent is right! Looks wonderful!!

    Like

  15. foodmuses Avatar

    My husband is going to LOVE this! Can’t wait to try it.

    Like

  16. J M Naszady Avatar
    J M Naszady

    I don’t often watch cooking shows, but I hapopened to see this being made once, with very thick slices of bread, minus the bananas. My mother loved peanut butter and bananas. On the show, they rolled the bread in oats as well, and seved it in a restaurant sliced in wedges, like cake, denched in syrup. Your recipe looks amazing. Bravo!

    Like

  17. Juliet Avatar
    Juliet

    Oh my, I definitely have to try this one. I’m sure my little guy will love it! Thanks for sharing! :0)

    Like

  18. storybookapothecary Avatar

    looks so good! haha @spoonandjar

    Like

  19. Peace Of Iran Avatar

    Oh my good grief charlie brown this looks DELICIOUS! I’m tempted to feign illness to leave work, swing by the grocery store, and make some of this delciousness for lunch!

    Like

  20. Caryn Avatar
    Caryn

    um, genius! i want to make this asap! and congrats on the blog success!

    Like

  21. Somer Avatar
    Somer

    That looks amazing!

    Like

  22. eatwithfatjoe Avatar

    YOU DA’MAN!!!

    Like

  23. didiita Avatar

    I have to try this! My husband will LOVE this!

    Like

  24. paisleycarrot Avatar

    I’ll be trying this as well. I may substitute Nutella, hmm…I’ll let you know. Thanks for this!

    Like

    1. Nicole Brait Avatar
      Nicole Brait

      Nutella – that sounds really good

      Like

  25. thebeadden Avatar
    thebeadden

    I can’t wait to try this one. Thanks!

    Like

  26. Lisa's Landscape & Design Avatar

    Holy Hell that looks amazing!!!

    Like

  27. terrepruitt Avatar

    Congrats. I have found that my post that are about food get the most views. Food is a “big thing”, a universal thing. Anyone anywhere can relate to it, even if the relation is “EWWWW. I would NEVER eat that.” They are still relating somehow.

    I am not sure about this. In somethings I am a purists. I like “plain” (egg and bread – no cinnamon, no vanilla, no other flavoring) french toast. But this sounds good. If I could eat French Toast everyday . . . . .

    Like

  28. Nicole Brait Avatar
    Nicole Brait

    Wow. Yum. I love PB and J and this is like PB and J on steroids.

    Like

  29. Chuck Avatar
    Chuck

    Looks might sweet. I might have to give that one a go one Sunday morning!

    Like

  30. magpiegazette Avatar

    Holy Moly ! That’s some eatin !

    Like

  31. budgetcookingblog Avatar

    An origins story! Thank you for sharing it!

    Like

  32. baconbiscuit212 Avatar

    What a great idea! Looks delicious.

    Part of me want to add bacon to the sandwich. Call it Elvis French Toast!

    Like

  33. pantryobsession Avatar

    This is wonderful! Have you ever seen Nigella Lawson’s Donut French Toast? No peanut butter in it but you reminded me that it’s been about 2 months since I’ve made it. I might make over the weekend and post it. There’s so many things you can do with french toast 🙂

    Like

  34. Catherine Avatar

    Aw yeah it’s great going back to that first spark. Mine was my best friend’s Blueberry Muffins, which I’m hoping she’ll be bringing out the recipe again soon since blueberry season is upon us.
    Good choice to add in the bananas and confectioners sugar. In my opinion, French Toast never seems complete without it some personal pzazz.

    Like

  35. scroungelady Avatar

    Add bacon to the bananas and you have most of Elvis’ dream sandwich!

    Like

  36. ML-X Avatar

    This looks delicious, what a way to add decadence to french toast! And congrats on the blog’s success 🙂

    Like

  37. Jennifer M. Avatar

    That’s a great story! PB&J is one of the first foods we love as children. It seems appropriate that it would be the catalyst to your blog’s success 🙂

    Like

  38. lulu Avatar

    Peanut butter and banana…how does it get any better? I’m putting a little of both in my smoothie this morning.

    Like

  39. Sara Avatar

    I’m going to make this over the weekend, but I made myself a small test serving of it this morning. So easy and yummy!
    For the “jelly” I used preserves mixed with some sugar free syrup – just heated it up and stirred. Yum yum yum…

    Like

  40. claudiagiulia Avatar

    An incredibly decadent breakfast, if I ever saw one! Lovely, lovely blog

    Like

  41. kaylakakes Avatar

    That looks awesome. I literally want to get out of bed and go make it right now.

    Like

  42. High Five for Friday « Didi's Blog Avatar

    […] I am planning on trying this recipe from Rantings of an Amateur Chef. Doesn’t it look absolutely amazing? I know for a […]

    Like

  43. princessepiggy Avatar

    THIS LOOKS ABSOLUTELY AMAZING. will try it ASAP!!!

    Like

  44. Lennie Avatar
    Lennie

    That looks amazing! My grocery store sells this peanut butter that is to die for. It’s crunchy (I’m talking whole nuts here), and swirled with honey. I can eat that stuff right out of the jar! I bet it’d be great in these.

    Like

  45. bucketdave Avatar

    This looks like something I could actually make. Thank you!

    Like

  46. magpiegazette Avatar

    Un – B – **** – Believable ! This has to be the most ! I used to make this for my girls when they were little girls. But I added cinnamon and honey …. I’m smiling ! Thanks.

    Like

  47. dheadd Avatar

    Wow this is one of my and my husbands favorite recipes but we have never tried it grilled like this. A must try!!!!! By the way thanks for stopping by my blog and liking my page. Clevelanders Rock!

    Like

  48. peaceloveandsmoothies Avatar

    This recipe looks simple, yet genius at the same time! I can’t wait to try it!

    Like

  49. […] I saw a post on rantingchef.com about peanut butter and jelly French toast sandwiches. Ever since then I’ve been trying to […]

    Like

  50. […] holiday, please revisit the following recipes that use or feature this ingredient: Buckeyes,   Peanut Butter Banana and Jelly French Toast, Peanut Butter Chocolate Brownies,  Peanut Noodles With Edamame, Slow Cooker Mongolian […]

    Like

  51. ittybittycitykitchenchef Avatar

    thanks for stopping by my blog! i too am a lover of writing and cooking and only recently had that lightbulb- duh-put-the-two-together moment! Keep writing. Kepp cooking : )

    Like

  52. aej Avatar
    aej

    Wow, a must try for this castle!

    Like

  53. The WordPress Cooking Challenge! | Healthy in All Hues Avatar

    […] Rantings of an Amateur Chef: PB & B & J French Toast  […]

    Like

  54. lpmendoza Avatar
    lpmendoza

    Hi Pat! Thanks for posting such an awesome and drool-worthy recipe! I will be cooking and writing about this dish in my “WordPress Cooking Challenge”. You can read more about the details here: https://healthyinallhuesblog.wordpress.com/2015/08/28/the-wordpress-cooking-challenge/ I will be sending my followers back to your blog for the original recipe, and I know they will enjoy your blog as much as I do. Have an awesome day! 🙂

    Like

  55. WordPress Food Challenge #6: Rantings of an Amateur Chef’s PB & B & J French Toast | Healthy in All Hues Avatar

    […] I am! Kicking off this stress-free, Labor Day weekend I decided that the perfect brunch meal was “Rantings of an Amateur Chef’s” recipe for PB & B & J French Toast. Let us all pause a moment to marvel at this simple culinary […]

    Like

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.